Myracle herself is quick to remind others that
for every documented request to challenge or ban a book, 4 or 5 additional
challenges go undocumented (Myracle, 2012). This results in only a few
instances of censorship attempts being made public. The following is a list of
some specific cases of Myracle’s works being challenged, banned, censored, or
acknowledged as such:
- In
2007, the book was challenged at the William Floyd Middle School in
Mastic, New York, for sexual situations and adult language. The book
remained in the library, with a spokesperson commenting that the book
deals with difficult topics without glorifying them (Banned books,
n.d.).
- In
2007, TTYL makes its first appearance on the American Library
Association’s “10 Most Challenged Books” list. (Tango tops most challenged
list, 2008).
- In
2009, TTYL was removed from the middle school libraries, and reshelved in
the high school libraries, at the Red Rock Independent School District in
Texas (Censorship Watch, 2009). -In 2009, TTYL, as well as the other books
in the Internet Girls series, topped the list of the 10 most frequently
challenged books as published by the American Library Association’s Office
of Intellectual Freedom (TTYL series tops 2009 list of challenged books,
2010).
- In
2010, TTYL was challenged at the Ponus Middle School in Norwalk,
Connecticut. The challenge went to a five member review committee, who
voted unanimously to keep the book in the library. The reasoning was that
the library should present a wide variety of books; the overwhelmingly
positive literary support for the book factored into this decision as well
(Success stories, 2010).
- In
2010, TTYL was challenged at the John Muir Middle School in Wausau,
Wisconsin, on the grounds of sexually explicit content; the book remained
(Banned books, n.d.).
- In
2011, the Internet Girls series once again topped the list of most
challenged books (Myracle, 2012).
- In
2016, parents of students from Nassau County School District in Florida
alerted the media when their children brought TTYL and TTFN home from the
school library. Parents told the media that they hoped the books would be
“done away with” and that more monitoring of the school library would
occur (Avitable, 2016).
- Myracle
states that a website named Virtue Alert sent out email directly stating
that “Satan is on the rampage, and his name is Lauren Myracle” (Corbett,
2011).
- Myracle
states that an email from a father named Chuck explained how he saw to it
that his child’s school removed Lauren’s books from the accelerated
reading program (Brannan, Chbosky, & Myracle, 2009).
No comments:
Post a Comment